BCCI has decided to remove the soft signals rule for the upcoming Indian Premier League 2021. India skipper Virat Kohli had recently spoken about the need to remove the soft signal rule when referring to a decision, that went against India, to the third-umpire and this point has been discussed by the Board of Control for Cricket in India as they have done away with soft signals for the upcoming IPL 2021.
In its updated playing conditions for this year’s IPL, the BCCI has clearly stated that the on-field officials would not be allowed to give soft signals when referring a decision to the third umpire. There is one clear change and it pertains to the usage of the soft signal in Appendix D – Clause 2.2.2 of the playing conditions before IPL 2021.
BCCI Decides To Remove Soft Signal Rule For Upcoming IPL 2021
The contentious rule came to the forefront in the fourth India-England T20I in Pune when England’s fielder Dawid Malan caught Suryakumar Yadav at the fine-leg boundary. Dawid Malan claimed the catch, but replays showed that he might have grassed it. The on-field umpire gave that out despite being far away from the action.
However, even after assessing multiple angles, the third umpire failed to find any such conclusive evidence that could have reversed the on-field decision. The batsman Suryakumar Yadav was eventually ruled out which raised a furor over how the on-field umpire can give a decision (read ‘soft signal’) when he does not have a clear sight of the incident in real-time.
“Soft Signal: On-field Umpire giving Soft Signal while referring the decision to the 3rd Umpire will not be applicable,” states the updated playing conditions for IPL 2021.
The decision to remove the soft signal has been taken so that the third umpire can make the best possible decision without keeping the on-field call in mind. Speaking to ANI, sources of BCCI in the know of developments said that the call to abolish the rule has been made to avoid any confusion in making umpiring decisions.
“There have been cases wherein the soft signal has kind of created confusion rather than giving clarity to the third umpire and that is why it was felt that going back to the old method of referring decisions to the third umpire if the on-field umpires are not sure should be followed,” the source said.
Speaking on the soft signal issue, Kohli had said: “If it hits the stumps or missing the stumps, it should not matter how much the ball is clipping because it is creating a lot of confusion. One more factor that needs to be considered is how the fielding team responds to a dismissal that is claimed. “
“This is somewhere defining the soft signals as well. You have to question what the spirit of the game is and what those guidelines are because if things like that happen with the Indian cricket team overseas then you are talking about a completely different conversation about the spirit of the game.”
“So look, it is a serious thing which needs to be considered because there is a lot at stake in bigger tournaments. You do not want any grey area hampering the game and it leaves with you no clarity.”
At BCCI’s insistence, the ICC eventually decided to amend the soft signal rule before the World Test Championship summit clash between India and New Zealand later in the summer. After the aforementioned T20I in Pune, which India won, Virat Kohli vouched for an ‘I don’t know’ call for the on-field umpires.
3rd Umpire To Check Short Run And Can Overturn On Field Umpires Decisions
There is also a major change in the updated guidelines of IPL as laid down by BCCI’s guidelines as pertaining to the case of short run, for which the third umpire can check whether it was a short run or not and the official can overturn the decision made by the on-field umpires.
“Short-run: In the case of the short run, the third umpire checks the short run and can overturn the decision made by the on-field umpires,” states the updated playing conditions for IPL 2021.
This short-run point became a huge debating point last year in the match between Kings XI Punjab (now Punjab Kings) and Delhi Capitals. The Punjab management also made an official complaint after they ended up on the losing side. As a measure to control the match timings, the 20th overs in each innings is now included in 90 minutes, earlier the 20th over was to start on or before the 90th minute.
In updated guidelines as per BCCI, now the third umpire can overrule the no-ball decision made by the on-field umpire. There is another updated clause as per BCCI’s guidelines in the playing conditions and it states that in an uninterrupted match, subsequent super overs can be played till an hour’s time from the actual finished time of the tied matches (Clause 16.3.1).