Andy Carroll (App: 44; Goals:6; 2011-2013):
If only for his price, the club’s record buy in Andy Carroll is easily one of the least productive purchases for Liverpool. Kenny Dalglish bought Carroll and Luis Suarez to Anfield after Fernando Torres was shipped off to Chelsea but the big man was not able to lead Liverpool’s attacking line and moved on after just 44 appearances for the club. He is still Liverpool’s costliest buy and also one of their worst.